Difference between revisions of "Welcome to the HacDC Wiki"

From HacDC Wiki

(Removing all content from page)
Line 1: Line 1:
== HacDC's MX record broken, can't send mail to lists ==

Dangit. I'm sure someone will find this here, as I'm unable to send to any of the mailing lists. Here's a convo between me and my admin:
12:39 <myself> hey, I keep getting this whenever I try to send to hacdc: <br/>
12:39 <myself> <br/>
12:39 <myself>'''    all relevant MX records point to non-existent hosts or (invalidly) to IP addresses '''<br/>
12:40 <myself> but there's plenty of traffic on the list, others obviously have no problems <br/>
12:40 <myself> I mentioned it to one of them through his personal email, and didn't hear back. Is this something you can look into? <br/>
13:03 <paul> paul@ptimmins-d:~$ host <br/>
13:03 <paul> has address <br/>
13:03 <paul> ''' mail is handled by 0 '''<br/>
13:03 <paul> that's invalid <br/>
13:03 <paul> cant' fix <br/>
13:04 <paul> '''mx records have to point to names per rfc''' <br/>
13:05 <myself> ahh, okay <br/>
13:05 <myself> thanks <br/>
13:05 <paul> that should be something like <br/>
13:05 <paul> MX 0 <br/>
13:05 <paul> with IN A <br/>
13:06 <myself> and everyone else's MTAs just silently accept the misconfiguration and do the right thing anyway <br/>
13:07 <paul> where by "the right thing" you mean "do what I mean not what I say" <br/>
13:07 <paul> yes <br/>
13:08 <paul> they added extra code paths to compensate for the dns calls not returning shit they should <br/>
13:08 <paul> when you pull an A record, the IPs get returned in binary <br/>
13:08 <paul> when you pull an MX record, it spells out the data in ascii because it's supposed to be another name <br/>
13:09 <paul> which you can then do a gethostbyname() on and get an ip <br/>
13:10 <paul> so other MTAs have an entire codepath where they try to parse an ASCII string of an IP address to stuff it into a connect() <br/>
13:10 <paul> which is as bad of an idea as it sounds, securitywise <br/>
Fixed - thanks for the heads up!

Revision as of 17:39, 30 April 2009